Chapter One: Introduction
Renewable energy is energy generated from natural resources that are renewable, constantly replenished by nature such as sunlight, wind, rain and geothermal heat. All of these forms of renewable energy can be used as a cleaner source of energy in houses. As these forms of renewable energy can be harnessed to generate sufficient electricity even for the most demanding of houses and then some, the electricity generated from renewable resource would be clean, safe, environmentally friendly, cost effective and efficient.
“Our present happy progressive condition is a thing of limited duration”
William Stanley Jevons 1865
This quotation shows that as far back as the mid 1800s civilisation knew the that worlds resources were not infinite and that one day they could run out, so for the past 150 years or so civilisation could have been planning for this and looking for alternative types of energy such as renewable energy.
“Traditional Fossil fuels are running out, they are getting harder and more expensive to obtain, and their emissions are polluting our planet. Newer, greener, alternative, renewable, energy solutions are available today. Emerging technologies are making them more efficient, and more affordable, with shorter payback times. This makes them a viable alternative to traditional energy sources.
Energy costs have snowballed in recent years. U.K energy wholesale prices have risen by 100% for electricity, and 230% for Gas since February 2007. Coal has seen a, massive jump with a 400% increase in the last 10 years, from just £23 a ton in 1999 to £100 a ton in 2008. Oil prices have increased dramatically recently and are always prone to fluctuation. Oil has reached peak supply and increasing demand from developing nations is likely to keep prices high”. (line.3,4,5. par 2 from home page of www.renewable alternative.co.uk website for Caron alternative energy systems.)
The Author found this quote to be very incisive as it not only shows that traditional fuels are no longer going to be an option in the future but with current demand for energy the price is going to sky rocket. This quotation also looks at how promoting and using renewable energy systems can help you to create a cleaner and more environmentally friendly environment, the quote also looks at how renewable systems can be more cost effective not only in the overall life span but also in the installation aswell as many governments of countries are now giving out grants to homeowners in order to promote renewable energy. The author will go into the details of the grants in greater detail later in the dissertation.
In this dissertation the author aims to show that installing renewable energy systems in domestic houses is not only encouraging green energy but also cost-effective and as productive as traditional heating systems in homes. Throughout the dissertation the author plans to name and describe the different types of renewable energy systems that are available to a dwelling to make it more energy efficient.
- To establish an appropriate research methodology to support the research needs of the dissertation.
- To analyse and assess the different types of renewable energy systems.
- Conduct a survey of consumers who have purchased/installed a renewable energy system in their house.
- To investigate the advantages and disadvantages between renewable energy systems and traditional heating systems.
- Formulate conclusions and make recommendations on the basis of my findings.
Is Renewable energy in domestic houses more beneficial than traditional heating systems?
Structure of Dissertation
Chapter one introduces the reader to the dissertation. It provides a brief overture to the topics that will be discussed in the dissertation. It also discusses the aims, objectives and the structure of the dissertation.
In chapter two the author discusses the research methodologies used to research information and this includes the research process, primary and secondary literature sources.
List of renewable energy systems
In chapter three the author makes a list of the different types of renewable energy systems available to the consumer.
List of traditional heating systems
In chapter four the author makes a list of the traditional heating systems available to the consumer.
Detailed description of renewable energy systems
In chapter five the author gives a detailed description of the different types of renewable energy systems and lists the advantages and disadvantages.
Detailed description of traditional heating systems
In chapter six the author gives a detailed description of the different types of traditional heating systems and lists the advantages and disadvantages.
Analysis of questionnaires
This chapter analyses the opinions of the home owners who have installed renewable energy systems in their homes. In this chapter the author has made up a customer survey and given it to home owners (who have installed renewable energy systems in there house) to complete. The author will compile and analyse the results of this survey.
In this chapter the author looks at different examples of similar research.
Conclusion and recommendations
This chapter provides the conclusions and recommendations of the dissertation.
Bibliography and References
The bibliography and references is a list of all the books, articles and websites used to research the dissertation
Chapter Two Research Methodologies
In this chapter the author outlines the various methods used to produce this dissertation. It identifies the different sources used and illustrates how with comprehensive research the information was collated. The author also discusses the limitations encountered in researching for this dissertation.
The research process begins by the author preparing a preliminary literature review. This enables the author to acquire a sufficient grasp of the theories and methods of analysis in renewable energy systems.
The preliminary literature review help the author develop his knowledge of the planning system and legislation. The preliminary literature study also helps expand an overview of the primary sources of information available. The preliminary literature study in the initial stages in the research process presents a large amount of the material needed for the dissertation. The author uses this information to narrow his research. This focused his intentions on specific areas. The author then had to decide on what format the dissertation would take and how to go about producing it. By studying past dissertations on similar subjects it will assist in the expansion of the initial idea and will demonstrate the correct method to execute a dissertation.
Throughout the research process different information is collected. This information can be broken up into different headings primary and secondary sources.
Sources: Primary and Secondary
Primary Literature Sources:
“Primary literature is the most accurate source of information as it publishes original research” (Naoum, 2007).
The lists of primary sources included in this dissertation were academic research journals, dissertations, government publications and reports on the subject matter. Discussion was carried out with the librarians in both Robert Gordon University and Carlow Institute of Technology this broadened the research avenues. The main sources of information included:
- Documents from the European Union
- Documents from the Irish government
- Sustainable Energy without the hot air by David JC Mackay
- Renewable Energy Policy by Paul Komor
Secondary Literature sources:
Secondary literature sources are those that cite primary sources such as textbooks, trade journals, newspaper articles etc. The secondary sources were mainly conducted during the author’s research period. The author used many different sources such as the internet and the library amenities available. The uses of search engines specifically orientated to renewable energy were of great significance to the author. The internet was a very good source for up to date material. The author concentrated on the local sustainability websites, Departments of Environment in Austria, Germany, Ireland, United Kingdom European Parliament, and the national newspaper websites to source information for this information.
During the research for this dissertation there were various limitations. One of the greatest limitations the author encountered was the time restriction. Accumulating the information needed time it takes time to process the information and assemble the dissertation.
A problem the author encountered was there were very few books that discussed the issues of the “the performance of renewable technology in domestic houses”. One other difficulty was the response rate was very poor to the author’s emails and letters. The response rate was very poor and thus effected the author’s overall objective view on this dissertation.
The author undertook a literature review to source the relevant research interests.
The literature review provided the background information for the rationale. In researching for this dissertation the author used textbooks, newspapers, legislation and published reports as the principal sources.
Past dissertations in the Robert Gordon University provided a valuable source of information. The past dissertations were a considerable help with the layout and format of the dissertation and also helped with developing the content.
The use of questionnaires was a significant help in receiving feedback from the people who are most influenced by the renewable energy systems (the people who have had them installed in there houses) on their opinions and experiences.
Chapter 3 List of Renewable Energy Systems
The list of renewable energy systems falls under certain different criteria for example solar, wind power, biomass etc. these are some of the systems that the author will be looking at in greater detail later on in the dissertation.
- Solar panels.
- Photovoltaic cells.
- Evacuated tube collectors.
- Geothermal heat pumps.
- Wind turbines
- Wood Chip or Pellet Boilers
- Rainwater harvesting
Chapter 4 List of Traditional Energy Systems
The list of traditional energy systems that the author has decided to research falls under the following criteria Gas, Oil and Coal the author will be looking at these systems in greater detail later on in the dissertation.
Traditional heating systems
Chapter 5 Detailed Description of Renewable Energy Systems
Solar thermal (heat) energy is often used for heating water used in homes and for heating the insides of buildings (“space heating”). Solar space heating systems can be classified as passive or active.
Passive space heating is what happens to your car on a hot summer day. The sun’s rays heat up the inside of your car. In buildings, the air is circulated past a solar heat surface and through the building by convection (meaning that less dense warm air tends to rise while denser cool air moves downward). No mechanical equipment is needed for passive solar heating.
An active solar thermal system relies on solar collectors to transform sunlight into heat that can be used for space heating or more commonly to produce hot water. Active systems often include some type of energy storage system. Information taken from: (http://www.eia.doe.gov/kids/energyexplained/renewable/flatplate.html)
Solar Energy & the Environment
Using solar energy produces no air or water pollution and no greenhouse gases, but does have some indirect impacts on the environment.
In addition, large solar thermal power plants can harm desert ecosystems if not properly managed. Birds and insects can be killed if they fly into a concentrated beam of sunlight, such as that created by a “solar power tower.” Some solar thermal systems use potentially hazardous fluids (to transfer heat) that require proper handling and disposal.
Concentrating solar systems may require water for regular cleaning of the concentrators and receivers and for cooling the turbine-generator. Using water from underground wells may affect the ecosystem in some arid locations.
What are Photovoltaic Cells and how do they work?
Photovoltaic Panels are usually situated on a roof and use semi conductors to convert sunlight to produce electricity for your home. Unlike Solar Panels which use the energy of the Sun to heat water, Solar PV (photovoltaic) converts the suns energy into electricity. The panels are made up of an array of cells which are made of materials such as silicon. The Solar PV’s are made up of a negative and positive field similar to a battery.
The photovoltaic panels do not require sunlight to be effective as they operate from daylight rather than sunlight specifically, although they do supply more electricity in sunnier climates. The more sun, the more electricity produced.
The photovoltaic cell is activated by light. Electricity is created by the creation of an electric field across layers of semi-conductors in the cell.
Advantages of Solar PV
- Photovoltaic cells are low maintenance, but do require checking of the wiring and ensuring the Photovoltaic panels are kept clean and debris free.
- For new build or renovations, photovoltaic installation costs will be lower as they can be incorporated with other works.
- Photovoltaic reduces your carbon footprint.
- Alternative energy systems can improve overall scoring for ‘Energy Performance Certificates’ which form a compulsory constituent of the Home Information Packs ‘HIPS’ which house sellers now have to compile.
- Alternative, renewable energy systems increase the value and saleability of your property.
- Photovoltaic panels are low noise.
- Photovoltaic panels can be used to supplement wind energy.
Photovoltaic panels should be placed so that they are South or mainly South facing to gain most benefit from them, on an area where they will not obstructed or overshadowed by buildings or trees. If they are in the shade for part of the time their output will be less.
Whilst traditionally these have been available in panels, Photovoltaic is now also available in a form which mimics traditional tiles, and also as units which can be used in the construction of conservatories where they can also provide shade.
For larger Photovoltaic installations you may require planning permission.
A individual system design will provide you with the best options for your individual needs. We are able to design and supply ‘off grid options’ which can allow you to be self sufficient for electricity, heating and hot water.
Photovoltaics (pvs) which convert sunlight directly into electricity, have many attractive features. They are quiet, dependable, have no moving parts, can be installed very quickly, and can be sized to power anything from a single light to an entire community. However they are quite expensive, with current costs of 20 per to 40 us cents per kWh for grid connected systems (compared to 3 to 5 cents per kWh for coal or natural gas systems). Although costs have come down considerably in recent years and will continue to drop ,PVs are currently nowhere near cost competitive with fossil fuels. (l.3,4,5 par.2 pg 39 Renewable Energy Policy by Paul Komor)
Evacuated Tube Collectors
Evacuated cellular tubes are made up of a series of modular tubes mounted in parallel .these tubes can be added to or taken away in accordance to hot water demands. These collectors consist of rows of parallel see through glass tubes in which each contain an absorber tube. In an evacuated tube collector the sunlight passes through the glass tube and heats up the absorber tube by means of a heat exchanger. The thickened fluid then flows back into the bottom of the heat pipe. The pipes must be placed at a certain angle so that the method of vaporization and compaction will work to the best of it’s capability.
Advantages of Evacuated Tube Collectors
- The tubes can be individually replaced easily without special tools and the water does not have to be drained from the solar hot water system.
- The E.C.T (evacuated tube collectors) work like a thermos and keep up to 93% of the suns heat in and lose between only 3-5% of the heat gained.
- The E.C.T will work in cold weather up to -40 degrees Fahrenheit.
Geothermal Heat Pumps
A geothermal heat pump is a central heating and/or cooling system that pumps heat to or from the ground. The geothermal heat pump uses the heat from the ground as a source of heat (in the colder months) or a heat storage (in the warmer months). This design takes advantage of the reasonable temperatures in the ground to improve efficiency and reduce the costs of operating heating and cooling systems.
The systems work a lot like a refrigerator or an air conditioner. Heat pumps can transfer heat from cold areas to warm areas, against the natural direction of run, or the systems can improve the natural surge of heat from a warm area to a cool one. But unlike air-source heat pumps, which predominantly transfers heat to or from the colder outside air, a ground source heat pump takes its heat from the ground. The fact that underground temperatures are much more constant means that geothermal heat pumps are much more energy efficient than air source heat pumps. What a ground source heat pump does is it extracts the heat from the ground in the colder months (for heating) and transfers the heat back into the ground in the warmer months (for cooling).
During the summer months, the procedure can be changed so that the heat pump takes the heat from the building and channels it to the ground.
In order for a ground source heat pump to work it must have a heat exchanger connected with the ground to remove or disperse heat. Direct exchange systems move refrigerant underground, closed loop systems use a combination of anti-freeze and water, where as natural groundwater is used in open loop systems.
“Geothermal electricity has one compelling advantage over wind and solar. It’s not limited by the whims of the wind or the sun and can therefore provide base load electricity. Typical geothermal plants operate at capacity factors of 90 percent, compared to wind’s 25 to 30 percent. This means that a geothermal power plant is delivering close to its maximum output most of the time. This makes it a much more valuable and dependable source of electricity”.
What are wind turbines and how do they work?
Wind turbines are the most common of the alternative energies, they are effectively the modern equivalent of the old fashioned windmill.
The rotors or blades of the wind turbines are placed on a pole high up, where they need relatively little wind to turn them. The spinning blades of the turbines create electricity by rotating a permanent magnet to generate electricity, which can be used for a variety of purposes.
The more electricity required the bigger the wind turbines required. When most people think of wind turbines they think of the very large commercial wind farms, with very high, very large wind turbines. Wind turbines are now available on a much smaller scale for domestic dwellings, and are capable of generating sufficient electricity for the household, and dependent upon size, there is also the possibility of selling excess electricity to the grid.
Advantages of Wind Turbines
- Wind turbines are environmentally friendly.
- Once installed wind turbines provide free electricity.
- Wind turbines are a more established technology, they are a cheaper option and have a lower payback period.
- During periods of good wind, electricity produced by Wind turbines and not used or stored can be sold to electricity companies.
- Our new generation wind turbines not only look different, they are quieter and more efficient. Their light-weight and compact design allows them to be located on building roofs.
In the main, wind turbines are used for supplementing an existing electricity supply.
You will need a suitable environment to be able to locate the turbine, as far away as possible from trees and buildings.
You will need a suitable base or plinth on which to mount the wind turbine.
Wind turbines only generate electricity while there is sufficient wind so a continuous supply of electricity cannot be achieved.
If there is no existing supply of electricity, electricity will either need to be stored for unproductive periods, and/or used in conjunction with another source of renewable energy.
Not all locations are suitable for wind turbines, the positioning of the turbine and the surrounding environment are critical for optimum performance.
Any local planning restrictions need to be taken account of in England and Wales planning permission is necessary to install a small wind turbine.
Wind turbines are best suited for rural properties, farms, community buildings, industrial estates, schools etc.
The fundamental idea behind wind power is appealingly simple: the wind turns the blades, the blades turn the generator, and the generator makes electricity. The reality of course is much more complex. Today’s wind turbines are technically sophisticated and finely engineered, incorporating the latest advances in materials, microprocessor controls, and computational fluid dynamics (for blade design) (line 5, par 2, pg 34 Renewable Energy Policy by Paul Komor)
“Most common process of biomass combustion is burning of wood. In developed countries replacing oil or coal-fired central heating boiler with a wood burning one can save between 20 and 60% on heating bills, because wood costs less than oil or coal. At the same time wood burning units are eco-friendly. They only emit the same amount of the greenhouse gas CO2 as the tree absorbed when it was growing. So burning wood does not contribute to global warming. Since wood contains less sulphur than oil does, less sulphate is discharged into the atmosphere. This means less acid rain and less acid in the environment”. (This is the opinion of the manufactures of the frohling company who manufacture biomass boilers.)
Biomass can be converted to different forms of energy including heat, power, combined heat and power or liquid bio fuels.
- Direct combustion of biomass material. Some processing of biomass may be carried out prior to combustion e.g. sorting, chipping, pelleting or drying.
- The chemical processes-where solid biomass is upgraded to a liquid or a gas by pyrolisis and gasification.
- Decomposition of solid biomass to liquid or gaseous fuels by processes such as anaerobic and fermentation.
Whilst the author was researching biomass energy he came across a very interesting article on the importance of biomass energy in Germany this is what it states “Biomass is one of the most important and most diverse renewable energy sources in Germany”. Quote taken from (http://www.bmu.de/english/renewable_energy/doc/42722.php).As Germany is one of the leading countries in sustainability in the European Union the author thought that this would be quite beneficial to the dissertation. Biomass can be used in solid, gas and liquid form to create electricity and heat and to produce bio-fuels. It is estimated that of the total final energy created from renewable sources in the year ending 2007 biomass contributed 69% this is a staggering figure when you take that more than two thirds of renewable energy came from biomass. According to the final energy consumption bio energy is responsible for almost 4 percent of total electricity use, just over 6 percent of total heat required and 7.6 percent of total fuel needed.
“The use of bio-energy is to be further expanded. The technical potential required for this is available in Germany. In the agricultural and forestry sector, part of the 17 million hectares of agricultural land (approx. 12 million hectares of arable land and approx. 5 million hectares of grassland) and of the 11 million hectares of woodland are available for biomass production.
By far the most important source of bioenergy in Germany is wood. About one quarter of Germany’s wood production (lower quality line of production) is used for generating energy, approximately three quarters are used as material. Waste wood and used wood are also used for energy production. Model calculations by the Federal Research Centre for Forestry and Forest Products have shown that there are reserves to expand the use of wood without impairing sustainable forestry.” quote taken from (http://www.bmu.de/english/renewable_energy/doc/42722.php) this quote shows how the German people are using there natural resources to further enhance the solution to fossil fuel problems.
Economically biomass energy has become quite significant in Germany with almost 100,000 jobs being created in the bio energy sector, specifically in the agricultural and forestry sections, where they are manufacturing materials such as pellets, wood chips or biogas from biomass. The total earnings from the bio-energy sector came to 10.23 billion euro in 2007.
(Information was taken from the website of the Federal Minister for the Environment, Nature Conservation and Nuclear Safety of the German Government)
Rainwater harvesting is the collecting and keeping of rainwater. It can provide water for drinking, for farm animals, for watering land and for water to refill acquifies in the process known as groundwater recharge. In some cases rainwater is the only sensible or available water source. The systems are very suitable in areas where the rainfall is greater than 200mm per year. There are two types of harvesting ground water harvesting and roof harvesting.
Ground water harvesting systems feed water from a prepared catchment area into a storage area. They are usually only considered in areas where rainwater is extremely limited and additional supplies of water are lacking or not available at all.
They are very suitable for small communities. If well designed, ground catchments systems can collect large amounts of rainwater.
Roof harvesting systems feed rainwater that falls onto a roof into storage through a system of gutters and pipes. The initial flurry of rainwater after a dry spell should not be stored as it could be polluted with dirt, bird droppings etc. Roof gutters must have sufficient slope to avoid any chance of a back log of water. The gutters must be strong enough, and big enough to carry maximum flows. In order to reduce the risk of contamination and fungus growth the storage tanks should be covered. In order for the Rainwater harvesting systems to be kept hygienic and clean they require regular cleaning and maintenance this will prolong the good working order of the systems.
Rainwater harvesting in towns or cities can be very useful for many reasons. One of the main reasons rainwater harvesting can be implemented in cities is to supply extra water for the city’s requirements, to replenish vegetation to improve the scenic beauty of a town/city, to increase the ground water table through artificial recharge, to alleviate urban flooding and to improve the quality of groundwater. Another reason that rainwater harvesting can be useful for is in households the water can be used to flush toilets and for washing clothes, sometimes it can be more beneficial to use rainwater to do laundry as some area the mains water may have traces of lime which could effect the washing machine over time. It can also be used for showering or bathing. It will require ultra violet treatment prior to use for drinking.
Chapter 6 Detailed Description of Traditional Energy Systems
In this chapter the author decided to look at the materials used to heat the traditional types of heating systems.
How Was Natural Gas Formed?
“The main ingredient in natural gas is methane, a gas (or compound) composed of one carbon atom and four hydrogen atoms. Millions of years ago, the remains of plants and animals (diatoms) decayed and built up in thick layers. This decayed matter from plants and animals is called organic material – it was once alive. Over time, the sand and silt changed to rock, covered the organic material, and trapped it beneath the rock. Pressure and heat changed some of this organic material into coal, some into oil (petroleum), and some into natural gas – tiny bubbles of odourless gas.”
Advantages of Natural Gas
The process of burning natural gas is cleaner than burning other fossil fuels. It releases fewer emissions of sulphur, carbon, and nitrogen than oil or coal. As natural gas is one of the cleaner fuels it has become much more popular in recent years.
Disadvantages of Natural Gas
Natural gas may be cleaner than other fossil fuels but like other fossil fuel, the burning of natural gas will produce carbon dioxide. Carbon dioxide is the second biggest greenhouse gas contributing to the greenhouse effect. Natural gas also has a negative effect on the environment while it is being manufactured, refining and transporting.
- Oil was created from the remains of plants and animals that existed millions of years ago in a maritime environment.
- Heating oil is a liquid with gluey features, it is a combustible liquid petroleum product used as a fuel for heating systems or boilers in buildings
- Heating oil is very similar to diesel fuel, and both are classified as distillates. It consists of a mixture of petroleum and hydrocarbons
Disadvantages of Oil
Oil products help us achieve many things. We use them oil products to fuel many of our transport systems such as automobiles, planes trains etc to heat our homes, and to develop products such as medicines and plastics. Even though oil products make life easier – discovering, manufacturing, transporting, and the use of them can harm the environment through water and air pollution.
Harmful gases and emissions are produced from burning Oil products.
Some of these harmful emissions include:
- Particulate matter (PM)
- Carbon dioxide (CO2)
- Sulfur dioxide (SO2)
- Carbon monoxide (CO)
Nearly all of these by-products of burning oil have a negative effect on peoples health and the environment:
- Carbon dioxide is a greenhouse gas, which is of course a source of global warming.
- SO2 is known to causes causes respiratory illnesses and heart diseases and also acid rain, which is damaging to animals and plants that live in water.
- Particulate matter is known to contribute to the following health problems lung cancer, emphysema, asthma and chronic bronchitis.
Coal is a readily combustible black or brownish-black sedimentary rock. It is composed primarily of carbon along with erratic amounts of other elements, primarily sulfur, hydrogen, oxygen and nitrogen.
Coal starts out as a film of plant substance builds up at the bottom of a body of water. In order for the procedure to continue the plant substance matter must be sheltered from biodegradation and oxidization, usually by mud or acidic water. This trapped atmospheric carbon in the ground in immense peat bogs that eventually were covered over and deeply buried by sediments under which they metamorphosed into coal.
Coal, a fossil fuel, is the largest source of energy for the generation of electricity worldwide, as well as one of the largest worldwide anthropogenic sources of carbon dioxide emissions. Coal is the largest emmittant of carbon dioxide of all the fossil fuels it emits almost double the amount of Co2 that natural gas emits. Coal is extracted from the ground by mining, either underground or in open pits. Coal is primarily used as a solid fuel to create heat and electricity.
What are some of the disadvantages with mining coal?
“Without proper care, mining can have a negative impact on ecosystems and water quality and alter landscapes and scenic views. Debris that chokes mountain streams can result from surface mining like mountaintop removal, and acidic water can drain from abandoned underground mines.
Today restoring the land damaged by surface mining is an important part of the mining process. Because mining activities often come into contact with water resources, coal producers must also go to great efforts to prevent damage to ground and surface waters.
What Emissions and By products Are Produced from Burning Coal?
The combustion of coal produces several types of emissions that adversely affect the environment. The five principal emissions associated with coal consumption in the energy sector are:
- Sulfur dioxide (SO2), which has been linked to acid rain and increased incidence of respiratory illnesses
- Nitrogen oxides (NOx), which have been linked to the formation of acid rain and photochemical smog
- Particulates, which have been linked to the formation of acid rain and increased incidence of respiratory illnesses
- Carbon dioxide (CO2), which is the primary greenhouse gas emission from energy use.”
Chapter 7: Analysis of Questionnaire:
In this chapter the author will assess some of the opinions of homeowners from Scotland and Ireland. These people represent the homeowners who have installed renewable energy systems in there houses of, so their opinions will give an honest view of the systems. The questionnaire will help me compare my own beliefs on the renewable energy systems with the people most accustomed to them.
The questionnaire was sent out with a cover letter as shown in Appendix A. There were 40 questionnaire sent out. 30 respondents sent their questionnaires back. I posted the questionnaires with a return stamp addressed envelope included.
How satisfied are you with regarding the following items?
Product, overall quality, value, installation (first use), usage experience and after purchase service.
The purpose of this question is to see whether the people who have purchased renewable energy systems are happy in the above areas. The results of the survey prove that large proportion of the people who have installed renewable energy systems in their homes have been predominantly happy with there purchase.
Overall, how satisfied are you with the product?
The results of this survey are fairly conclusive in proving that the majority of the people surveyed are either very satisfied or extremely satisfied with there product.
Compared to other products that are available, would you say that the product is?
The purpose of this question is to see whether the people who have purchased renewable energy systems are happy with there products compared to traditional energy systems. Looking at the results of the questionnaire it is obvious to see that the people who have had the renewable systems installed are happy with there purchase with a majority of 53% finding the new system to be better and 27% of the people.
Would you go back to your old system?
The purpose of this question was to find out what percentage of the people surveyed would be happy to go back to there original system. Once again the results of the survey were fairly conclusive with the majority of the people more than happy to stay with there renewable systems.
How likely are you to recommend this product to others?
The purpose of this question was to find out what percentage of the people surveyed would be happy to recommend this product to there friends and family.
The results of this question shows that out of 30 people who answered the questionnaire a majority of 54% of people would be willing to recommend a renewable energy system to people they know, with 30% of the people being undecided.
Based on your experience with this kind of product, how likely are you to install a similar product in your house again?
The results of this question are very concise with a majority of 73% likely or extremely likely to install a similar renewable energy system in the future and a minority of 23% who would not be willing to install another renewable energy system.
Chapter 8: Case Study
As part of the case study chapter the author has looked at the new E.U. legislation brought in on the 23rd January 2008 entitled “Renewable Energy in the 21st century : building a more sustainable future”. This initiative is aimed at having Renewable energy account for 20 percent of the unions overall Energy consumption by 2020. As part of this case study the author looked at how four different countries namely Austria, Germany, Ireland and the United Kingdom intend to meet firstly the interim targets and secondly there overall target by 2020. The author will also be looking at the different grant schemes grants for renewable energy in domestic homes awarded by different countries within the European Union. Firstly the author will show the legislation given by the EU below and show what targets have to be met by each country in the European union and the interim targets set out for each country listed below.
Member states’ targets
On 23 January 2008, theCommission put forward a proposal for a newdirective on renewable energies to replace the existing measures adopted in 2001.EU governments and the European Parliament reached a broad agreement on the proposal on 9 December 2008, which was then adopted by the Parliament in a plenary vote on 17 December
According to the text, each member stateshouldincrease its use ofrenewable energies – such as solar, wind or hydro -in a bidto boost the E.U.’s share from 8.5% of the bloc’s energy mix today to 20% by 2020.A 10%use of ‘green fuels’in transportis also included within the overall EU objective.
To achieve the targets, every nation in the 27-member bloc is required to increase its share of renewables by 5.5% from 2005 levels, with the remaining increase calculated on the basis of per capita gross domestic product (GDP):
The Commission alsoproposes aseries of interim targets, in order to ensure steady progress towards the 2020 targets.
- 25%average between 2011 and2012;
- 35% average between 2013 and 2014;
- 45% average between 2015 and 2016, and;
- 65% average between 2017 and 2018.
In researching the proposals of each of the four countries the author intended to look at, the author found it extremely difficult to find a finalised proposal as the finalised proposals do not have to be submitted to the European Union until June of 2010. the best the author was able to do was research proposals forwarded by MPs to each government.
The Austrian government set up a program to analyse the effects of having to reach 34% renewable energy of the total energy output by 2020 and the impact this will have on the environment, the economy and on society. In order to analyse the questions posed, the project comprises two main blocks: the development of the simulation model “e3.at” which integrates energy, economic and environmental aspects in one single and consistent modelling framework, and its application within a participatory scenario modelling process. After the creation of the simulation model and the development of the scenarios, the scenarios had to be implemented into the model.
The project consists of:
- An economic model, consisting of an input-output model, the system of national accounts (SNA), and the labour market.
- An energy model, illustrating the relationship between economic development, energy use and CO2 emissions. It comprises energy demand, transformation and supply.
- A resource model, allocating the domestic and imported material inputs to those sectors responsible for the material extraction.
The model acts as a basis for quantifying the effects of different scenarios of a more ambitious use of renewable energy in Austria.
The German government has estimated that they will not only reach the target by 2020 but beat it by .7% the government. The German government have done up a table estimating how much percentage of energy they are going to make from renewables from 2010 to 2020.
According to the Irish governments department of communication, marine and renewables white paper document, delivering a sustainable future for Ireland the government intends to do the following:
- Encourage biomass in power generation by supporting biomass technology transfer, investment in specific biomass R & D and tackling of supply side (biomass feedstock) issues;
- They will eliminate the dedicated oil demand for the power generation sector by 2020 while reviewing the strategic necessity for dual firing at gas plants;
- They will achieve 15% of electricity consumption from renewable sources by 2010through existing and new projects under the refit scheme;
- They will achieve 33% of electricity consumption from renewable sources by 2020 through support for research, development, commercialization, and technology transfer as well as grid connections and planning issues for offshore wind, ocean technology and biomass;
- They will limit Irelands dependence on natural gas for power generation to approximately 50% by 2020.
- They will ensure the necessary transmission system planning and development in support of renewables by EirGrid SONI and the Regulators in the all-island framework.
Also in the white paper document was a estimated table of the electricity generation between 2005 and 2020.
In relation to the United Kingdom the author was able to come across a proposal by Mr John Hutton MP outlining his proposals to help the United Kingdom reach its recommended renewable energy target of 15% by 2020. The proposals are as follows:
- “Extending and raising the level of the renewables obligation to encourage 30-35% of our electricity to come from renewable sources by 2020.
- Introducing a new financial incentive mechanism to encourage a very large increase in renewable heat.
- Extending more effective financial support for heat and electricity microgeneration technologies in homes and other buildings.
- Helping the planning system to deliver.
- Ensuring appropriate incentives for new electricity grid infrastructure.
- Exploiting the full potential of energy from waste by considering further restrictions on land filling biomass.
- Requiring all biofuels to meet strict sustainability criteria to limit adverse impacts on food prices, and other social and environmental concerns.
- Encouraging the development of new renewable technologies by ensuring effective support particularly where the UK has the potential to be a market leader.
- Maximising the benefits for UK business by providing a clear long-term policy framework.”Taken from (http://www.energyportal.eu/component/content/article/6175.html)
Chapter 8.2 Grant allocation
As part of this dissertation the author researched the grants available to homeowners, who wished to install renewable energy systems in there dwellings. The author decided to look at the grants available in the four European countries he had looked at for the E.U initiative namely Austria, Germany, Ireland and the United Kingdom. The author thought that this would be very beneficial as the main reason for not installing renewable energy systems in peoples homes was the price of it, but if the grants available can be substantial enough to cut the price of installation down to a minimum then there should be no reason for not installing renewable energy systems.
Some European countries, such as Germany, Ireland, Portugal and Spain, already established renewable building codes on a national level. Austria has chosen a different path. Instead of an amendment to the existing building codes, which would make a share of renewable energy mandatory in new or refurbished buildings, Austria agreed on a regulation which is linked to the housing assistance programmes. The framework for this political instrument is an accord (paragraph 15a B-VG) between the national and the state governments to reduce the greenhouse gas emissions of the building sector. It stipulates that all Austrian states implement rules for paying housing assistance only if the heating system of the house fulfils certain ecological requirements.
Efficient oil/gas boilers with a solar thermal system are eligible in most states, as well as wood boilers, heat pumps and district heating. 7 of 9 Austrian states already approved these requirements last year.
Austrian states that implemented requirements for an ecological heating system for new and refurbished residential buildings, wanting to profit from housing assistance. In most cases, the homeowner can choose between different heating technologies, one of them being an efficient oil/gas boiler combined with a solar thermal system.
According to the German government they are allocating 350 million euros each year to in the form of grants to homeowners for the installation of renewable energy systems such as solar panels, biomass boilers and heat pumps. However the German government expects most homeowners to choose solar panels. Under the new regulations, solar panels will need to have an area equal to 4% of the total area of a house.
The German government has also brought in a legislation that all new homes built in Germany from January 1st 2009 will be required to install renewable energy heating systems under a new law called the Renewable Energies Heating Law (Erneubare-Energien-Warmegesetz). According to the new legislation 14% of a household’s total energy consumption must be met by renewable energy sources. For existing houses from 2010 onwards the recommendations are that 10% of the heating and domestic supplies will have to be provided by incorporating renewable energy. For old houses, 10% of the heating and domestic hot water energy needs will have to be provided by renewables. Fines of up to 500,000 euros will face anyone who fails to switch their heating systems. (information for this was taken from the German federal ministry for the environment, nature conservation and nuclear safety of the German government)
In Ireland the Irish government have been giving out grants to home owners since the 27thof march 2006 under the grant scheme the applicant.
The United Kingdom also allocates grants to homeowners who are installing renewable technology in there houses but certain standards have to be met first these standards are as follows:
The grants are only available to home that have:
- Insulated the whole of the loft of the property to meet current building regulations e.g. 270mm of mineral wool loft insulation or suitable alternative.
- Installed cavity wall insulation where possible.
- Fitted low energy light bulbs in all appropriate light fittings.
- Have thermostatic controls and a programmer or timer for your heating.
In many of the grants available the grants will also pay for 30% of the installation fee.
So in conclusion with the grants in each of the four countries researched covering at least 30% of the installation fee if not more there should be no reason for not installing renewable technology systems.
The main aim of this dissertation is to identify whether the renewable energy systems could work as if not better than the traditional heating systems . The second aim was to uncover if the renewable energy systems be more cost effective and significantly more environmentally friendly than the existing heating systems. In order to fulfil these aims and to test the hypothesis of “Is Renewable energy in domestic houses more beneficial than traditional heating systems? the author set out specific objectives to achieve these goals.
In the ever changing world of renewable energy it is evident that the advances and ongoing advances in the field of renewable energy means that better technology will be bought at a more competitive price. This will bode well for both the consumer and the environment with the consumer being able to purchase renewable technology cheaper than he would a traditional fossil fuel he/she will be cutting down on the greenhouse gas emissions that are polluting the environment every day. To show one example of this Evacuated cellular tubes are possibly the best solar thermal devices on the market right now but they are also the dearest but with advances in technology (e.t.c’s) will become cheaper making them more popular.
Another conclusion that the author came to while he was researching for this dissertation is that not only is the usage of fossil fuels seriously harming our environment but they are also running out at an alarming rate which means if we don’t act as soon as possible to correct our mistakes we will not only have created irreversible damage to our environment, by emitting harmful gases into the atmosphere but we will have sucked dry all of the earths fossil fuels. It is quite clear to see this happening now all we have to do is look at the soaring prices of oil, gas and coal e.g. prices have risen 230% for Gas since February 2007. Coal has seen a, massive jump with a 400% increase in the last 10 years, from just £23 a ton in 1999 to £100 a ton in 2008. figures taken from (Caron alternative energy website.)
Results from the who installed renewable energy systems in there homes were more than happy questionnaires, proved that 74% of the people that were surveyed with either the heat generated or the electricity generated and the comfort provided by the renewable energy systems. As the majority of the people surveyed either switched from traditional heating systems to renewable energy systems or were brought up in living in a house with traditional heating systems the author thought that this was a true reflection of the view of the people most affected.
- There should be more emphasis put on the manufacturing of renewable energy systems as the author noted earlier if there were more renewable devices supplied then the overall price would go down as it is simple marketing “supply and demand”
- Although the European Union have brought in a new directive where by 2020 40% of the collective European countries energy should be renewable energy, the author believes that each government in each country should do its utmost to surpass this requirement.
- The government of each country should bring in a legislation that all new houses have to meet a certain standard of renewable output to promote both the sale and use of renewable energy. The government should also consider introducing stricter time frames for enforcement of this legislation.
- Governments could also give greater grants to promote the sale of renewable systems and tax an over use of fossil fuels.